The Circus Is In Town (but you’re not invited)

It’s 7am in Durban. I’ve just bought a cup of coffee to go (needless to say, once COP-17 started I soon abandoned my no-caffeine regiment) and am on my way to the International Convention Centre (ICC).

“Madam, madam! Are you with the press?” I hear a man shout behind me. Before waiting for my answer, he says, “the television won’t show what’s happening in the streets of Durban, madam”. He (I later learn his name is Joshua) goes on to tell me that he has been living on the streets for 25 years. Joshua explains that Durban’s street people are being cleared from the streets in a sweep to make the city more ‘attractive’ in the eyes of the thousands of visitors here for COP-17.

“They’re taking children, madam. Children! The police come, the metro police, and they are taking entire families”. Joshua is visibly outraged. He urges me to tell others about what is happening, and I promise to do so. We part ways at an intersection, waving.

While the Durban police are cleansing the streets from its traces of poverty, COP-17 delegates have it pretty good inside the ICC, with its air conditioning, free wifi, and immaculate washrooms. A maid can be found at all times in the ladies’ washrooms, wiping up drops of water from the sink after a delegate washes their hands, and mopping the floor whether it needs it or not. I enjoy a running joke with the woman who seems to be in charge of cleaning the washroom nearest the CYD booth; we both chuckle at how often I come to pee (it’s like 30 degrees outside – got to stay hydrated!).

The brand new infrastructure combined with the heavily packaged and overpriced food, the smart phones, the business cards, the suits, the ties…. All this makes for a pretty disillusioning experience. My feet are covered in blisters from wearing ‘business casual’ shoes, and it’s too hot to wear a blazer but on some days I feel compelled to do so, if only to be granted the respect that this sort of attire seems to demand here at the UNFCCC. It’s as if we’re all playing dress up – except that climate change is no joke. There’s a lot going on here at the ICC, but so far, climate action isn’t one of them – and that’s the most disillusioning part of all this.

It’s no wonder that local organizers have developed a circus narrative around COP-17 –“because nothing undermines authority like holding it up to ridicule”. They’ve poignantly dubbed these negotiations the Conference of Polluters. It’s becoming increasingly clear to me that these negotiations are, at least in practice, driven by the fossil fuel industry and its stakeholders. The designated free speech zone outside the conference (a triangular patch of grass in the middle of a busy intersection) can only accommodate a maximum of 500 people… this when climate change is expected to cause 300,000 deaths per year by 2020, and displace hundreds of millions of others.

The circus is in town, but the majority of Durban’s inhabitants, not to mention the people of the world on the frontlines of climate change, aren’t invited.

I run into Joshua again later in the evening. Now it’s raining. He calls my name from under the awning of a closed café and we wish each other a good night. He will remain well hidden tonight, for fear of being taken by the police. I return to the dormitory in my hostel. Canada’s negotiators return to their fancy hotel on the beach. The Earth keeps warming.

5 Responses to “The Circus Is In Town (but you’re not invited)”
  1. kbardswich says:

    This is a very powerful post and it’s something I hadn’t noticed. But when you point it out, it’s so obvious that there’s been a “cleansing” process on Durban’s streets. I included part of your post in my most recent blog post about some of the interesting things I’ve been reading while in Durban:

  2. Alison says:

    From another Canadian in town, working with a Human Rights NGO – I just thought I would clear up one thing in this post. I had a meeting this morning with 4 organizations that work with street kids in central Durban. These four organizations were very pleased to report this morning that all of the lobbying and pressure in the press that went on about a month ago seems to have been fairly effective in pressuring Metro not to conduct the same types of round-ups of street kids that happened last year before World Cup. And believe me we were ready to go after Metro if actual round-ups were taking place. Also, it is not to say there have not been individual incidents, but I don’t think it is fair to say that the street kids are being rounded up en masse.
    There is no doubt in my mind that Durban is putting on a show, the beachfront is a perfect example. And there is no doubt certain abuses of human rights have taken place, but I just wanted to be fair in recognizing the work of the NGOs who advocate on behalf of street kids and acknowledge that their work in the past few months has helped to reduce the number of kids who are being taken by the police to remote areas of the municipality and who have been subject to abuse.

  3. citizenxt says:

    well, certainly, this is not a new situation or strategy. Think World Cup soccer last year, FIFA delegates arriving to view the cities and stadiums. There was a massive clean-up of the dirty street people, in an attempt to make the city seem safe and ‘friendly’.

    the truth is, people, Durban is an illusion in itself. Held up in media spin as being a leading city for ‘low carbon’ and amazing water policy, the truth is, ALL delegates that wander outside are breathing in toxic fumes spewed forth from the ‘Valley of Death’ just south if the city edges.
    Durban has amazing spin doctors that manage to fool the outside viewer and in the inhibitor alike, that everything is fine and its all gonna be alrite.

    its not. and in being itself, Durban holds the ultimate mirror up to the COP circus. Almost nothing you hear through the media is true. the people we have elected to manage our resources, do not have the global maturity to create a realistic future where we can live in harmony with nature.

    so im not sure where this leaves us. clearly, the process is not working, the people we have mandated to create solutions are puppets of the Greed Monster, and ultimately, The People must move as One and decide

Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] the Canadian Youth Delegation blog is pretty awesome, and they update a lot. I just saw their posting about the police in Durban clearing the city of street people, and it’s just appalling. But […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: